Out on the water with Hall’s Diving Center in the Florida Keys

On April 23, 1982, the mayor of Key West, Florida, Dennis Wardlow, “broke a loaf of stale Cuban bread over the head of a man dressed in a naval uniform.” This naturally ushered his city into secession from the United States, officially as the “Conch Republic.”

One minute into sovereignty, Prime Minister Wardlow surrendered to the same man, and the union was restored. He then requested one billion dollars in foreign aid, which he did not get.

Why did this happen? Well, Wardlow and his city council had been campaigning Washington for months to end a US Border Patrol roadblock and inspection station on US-1, the main thoroughfare into the Florida Keys. The checkpoint was choking the flow of traffic, and in turn Keys tourism. Shortly after the secession, the roadblock was lifted, and tourism numbers began to rise once more. And in fact, they kept rising. In the wake of Wardlow’s very public spectacle, the “Conch Republic”—a moniker now bestowed on the whole of the Keys, not just Key West—was given life.

Flying a water jetpack

This bizarre tale of independence provides a very interesting perspective with which to assess the Keys today, because the Florida Keys are simply unlike anywhere else I’ve been in the US. They’re not Florida, but they’re not quite the Caribbean either. They exist somewhere in between, tethered to American convention only by a narrow bridge and otherwise floating contently in turquoise waters all their own.

I did not know any of this in January. Truth be told, I accepted an invitation to visit this winter because the itinerary included hang gliding (we didn’t end up going, but there was plenty of adventure), but I returned home with a genuine fondness for the Keys’ very unique, very independent way of life. Perhaps caught up in the adventure, I even returned to Key West (which I missed the first time) myself a few months later. Here’s what I found:

More on the Conch Republic:

Mile Markers (MM) denote relative location (in miles, from Key West) on the Overseas Highway (US-1), which connects Florida City at the beginning of the Keys to Key West. In MMs, that’s MM127.5 to MM0. In the guide that follows, the journey begins at 127.5, in mainland Florida.

Dave with Hall’s Diving

MM127.5–>MM0 A cast of colorful characters
Top to bottom, the citizenry is strikingly not Floridian, with many residents having “immigrated” (people kept saying this) from all over the country—from northern Florida, yes, but also from New York, New Jersey, California, and on and on. No one’s really from the Keys, and so what matters more than divergent backstories is the shared love for the Keys lifestyle. Days are slow and easy, and people are happy.

Examples of happy guys:

  • The water jetpack guy (more below) who cashed in a career in wealth management (his colleagues went to prison!) in New York so he could be remembered as the water jetpack guy.
  • Guy who captained our snorkeling adventure. A retired New Jersey cop and goddamn thrilled with his Keys life.
  • The guy who managed chairs at a beach I visited in Key West. Upbeat, full of jokes, from California.
  • Tour guy at the Ernest Hemingway House, from Florida, with dry sense of humor and enthusiastic sandwich recommendations.

MM127.5–>MM0 — Free refills
This turned out to be a difficult thing to confirm across the board, but non-alcoholic beverages came with free refills everywhere we ate. This seemed to be a natural extension of a happy, inclusive populace—living somewhere outside US norms. It also seemed to be Happy Hour a lot more than I was used to.

MM102.4The Fish House
A casual, Keys-style ode to fresh fish. Your options change based on the day’s catch, but any fish will probably be good Matecumbe-style (baked and topped with tomatoes, shallots, capers, basil, olive oil, and lemon juice) at The Fish House.

MM100.2 — Key Largo Conch House
Key Largo Conch House claims their conch fritters are the best anywhere. A lot of places will make that claim in the Conch Republic, but Man vs Food chose this one, and they really are good.

Man vs Food: Florida Keys: Here’s the episode on the Florida Keys, which features Key Largo Conch House

MM84Tiki Jet Jetpack Adventures
To introduce the water jetpack (watch the whole thing):

There are only a select number of spots in the country (and so the world) that you can strap on a water jetpack and fly around like a cartoon villain. San Diego, in the video, has one of them, and Tiki Jet Jetpack Adventures in Islamorada is another. Unlike in the video, experiences at Tiki Jet take place away from the dock and include a guide/instructor who is 1) absolutely thrilled with his life and 2) there to walk you through every step of the way. It’s bananas, and insanely fun. I flew up about 25 feet, forward with pretty good pace, and even beneath the water, breaking the surface like a dolphin as commanded by my instructor. He also convinced me to do a backflip purely to experience that style of collision with the water, and I don’t recommend that.

Overall, though, even noting a comically hard fall in our group, it’s completely safe.

Fact: The full jetpack setup costs the owner (not you) over $100,000.

MM83History of Diving Museum
In one of world capitals of diving, the History of Diving Museum offers a unique look at nearly 3,000 years of diving history with an impressive collection that includes a near-unprecedented array of helmets. Behind it all is treasure hunter Art McKee, who again is a treasure hunter.

MM82 — Cheeca Lodge & Spa
In Islamorada, at MM82, is perhaps the preeminent hotel/resort in the Florida Keys. Cheeca Lodge & Spa is an exceptionally elegant estate of a place (it’s 27 acres), complete with free on-property golf, three top-notch restaurants, palatial rooms, mango and banana trees, and a whole lot of history (it’s been named one of Travel + Leisure’s 500 Greatest Hotels in the World). When it opened in 1941, Harry Truman was the first guest, and he wasn’t the last president to come for a stay (or host a fishing tournament), as the photos in reception make clear.

Pier and beach from my Cheeca room

Among the other plusses are a complimentary shuttle service that will take guests anywhere within “reasonable distance” of the lodge, a top-rated spa (you can opt to get your treatments on the beach), and the longest private pier in the Keys. From my own two days here, I have to mention the intensity with which people insisted I check out the bathtub on the balcony of my room. If you like bathtubs, note that.

Rates start at $249/night.

Cheeca deals available as of August 15:

  • Midsummer’s Nights Free —  Complimentary night with every two-night midweek stay until October 9 (Sun-Thurs stays; from $173/night)
  • Family Summer Splash Package — $50 daily resort credit, daily fruit smoothies for 4, and half off Camp Cheeca charges for children with stays of two nights or more (from $448 for two nights)

MM81.6Chef Michael’s
Chef Michael’s has been described as having the “the best variety of freshly caught fish in Islamorada.” Chef Michael the man is originally from New York and spent time corralling flavors in the Caribbean before the move to MM81.6, where he specializes in hogfish. The menu changes daily based on catch, but hogfish in some style will usually be there.

Wakeboarding at Tiki Jet

MM59Keys Cable and Otherside Adventure Park
This place was great. Run by still more elated out-of-Republic transplants, Keys Cable and Otherside Adventure Park is a lot of different things—but most notably an achievement in wakeboarding. A quarry-turned-lagoon and pully mechanism have removed the need for a boat entirely, and so as long as you don’t fall, you can just ride the pully-driven loop around and around. And if you do fall, there’s a guy looking over you who will start things back up on your signal. There’s also a park version, with jumps, and instruction is available for an added cost. Without instruction, it costs $22/half hour and $32/hr (plus rental costs).

As for the aesthetic, the whole property had a kind of post-Apocalyptic tropical commune feel in the best way I can mean that. And that’s a tribute to the hard work put in by founders Mike and Shana Walsh and team, who’ve brought the place back to life from complete disrepair. With Keys Cable progressing towards its goals of “Organic Growth”—growing vegetables and completing their Action Sports-Eco Farm, to start—there are only more good things to come.

MM50Keys Fisheries
It’s an inconspicuous, slightly weathered fish shack right on the water in Marathon. Most famously, Keys Fisheries has a lobster reuben ($14.95) that’s pretty delicious. You’re also asked to leave the name of a TV show instead of your name to be called out when your order is ready.

Lobster reuben: Pics and mixed reviews on Foodspotting

The snorkeling spot with Hall’s

MM48.5Hall’s Diving Center and Career Institute
Hall’s Diving Center and Career Institute is a first-rate diving and snorkeling operation, possibly because they’ve funneled their website budget into other aspects of the business. As noted above, captain Dave and his team were a joy to be on the water with. The Keys have earned esteem as one of the world’s premier diving locations, so if that’s what you’re after, Hall’s can take you to a number of dive spots (for $65-75 for four hours). We went snorkeling, which is $45 for four hours, and it was great. At one point, I ended up inside a school of 10-12 five-foot barracudas. That is not dangerous, I guess, but that is a lot of barracudas.

Barracudas: More from Wikipedia

MM48.5Turtle Hospital
I wouldn’t go again, but it was really interesting to see a turtle being operated on by human doctors. They do a lot of good at the Turtle Hospital, and that good includes rehabbing and caring for turtles with such names as Dirk and Francis. If you like turtles, or animals in a general way, you should check it out. It’s also 30 seconds from Hall’s Diving Center.

MM48.5Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort
The #1 rated property in Marathon on TripAdvisor, Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort brings exactly what its name promises. The resort is comprised of 87 two-to-three-bedroom beach houses, which are functionally owned by individuals and are rented out year-round, and in mid-December, 16 one-bedroom beach houses (similarly available for rent) were added. There is a private 2.5-acre crescent beach, whose arc creates a sort of private bay in which we saw dolphins at sunset one night. And tranquility reigns here. There was 88% occupancy on our first night, and it felt as though we had it to ourselves.

Room rates start around $230/night, with September and October identified by management as the best times of the year to go.

The beach and bar at Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort

MM0Ernest Hemingway Home & Museum
He’s an all-time literary great, an American icon and somehow more of a legend to each passing generation. Ernest Hemingway spent some of his most accomplished years at the address now receiving mail as the Ernest Hemingway Home & Museum, and the tour ($16/30-minutes long) is worth it. Though the property is mostly cats.

MM0 — Louie’s Backyard
A glowing Zagat’s review has done nothing but good things for business at Louie’s Backyard, where the food impressively keeps pace with the setting: a refurbished Victorian home that backs right up to the Atlantic. It’s more of a back porch than a backyard, but the experience is worthwhile. Get reservations to be safe.

MM0Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie Shoppe
National Geographic and Food Network have weighed in and Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the best Key Lime Pie on the island.

MM0 The Marker Waterfront Resort (opening in October)
It’s not open yet, but come October, The Marker Waterfront Resort is likely to rock the Key West hospitality landscape. The 96-room luxury hotel benefits from a prime location in the heart of Key West’s Old Town and sleek, locally inspired design. The “Conchierge” service, available to all guests as a personal, insider guide to the island, sounds interesting, but we’ll have to wait until October to find out for sure.

Room rates are set to start at $329/night.

For more information on the Florida Keys, check out their website here.

One of many jacuzzis hidden around Cheeca
Pier and beach from my Cheeca room
Happy guy at Tiki Jet
Room at Cheeca Lodge & Spa
Bathroom at Cheeca Lodge & Spa
Wall of helmets at the History of Diving Museum
Turtle medicine at the Turtle Hospital
Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort from the front
Room at Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort
The beach and bar at Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort
Hall's Diving Center and Career Institute
Dave with Hall's Diving
The Keys from the boat with Hall's
The snorkeling spot with Hall's
Out on the water with Hall's Diving Center in the Florida Keys
Sunset at Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort
Flying the jetpack
Wakeboarding at Keys Cable
Lagoon at Keys Cable and Otherside Adventure Park

Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

  • Our best offer ever! Earn 100,000 bonus points after you spend $4,000 on purchases in the first 3 months from account opening. That's $1,250 when you redeem through Chase Ultimate Rewards®.
  • Enjoy new benefits such as a $50 annual Ultimate Rewards Hotel Credit, 5X points on travel purchased through Chase Ultimate Rewards®, 3X points on dining and 2X points on all other travel purchases, plus more.
  • Get 25% more value when you redeem for airfare, hotels, car rentals and cruises through Chase Ultimate Rewards®. For example, 100,000 points are worth $1,250 toward travel.
  • With Pay Yourself Back℠, your points are worth 25% more during the current offer when you redeem them for statement credits against existing purchases in select, rotating categories.
  • Get unlimited deliveries with a $0 delivery fee and reduced service fees on eligible orders over $12 for a minimum of one year with DashPass, DoorDash's subscription service. Activate by 12/31/21.
  • Count on Trip Cancellation/Interruption Insurance, Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver, Lost Luggage Insurance and more.
  • Get up to $60 back on an eligible Peloton Digital or All-Access Membership through 12/31/2021, and get full access to their workout library through the Peloton app, including cardio, running, strength, yoga, and more. Take classes using a phone, tablet, or TV. No fitness equipment is required.

The comments on this page are not provided, reviewed, or otherwise approved by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Editorial Note: The editorial content on this page is not provided by any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

5 Comments On "Mapping the Conch Republic"
  1. Jim Cook|

    Love the article & love the site

    1. Ian Livingston|

      Thanks Jim!

  2. Colleen Adams|

    The most beautiful place to live and vacation

  3. Shela Holland|

    my husband and I are campers and visit Key West for two months in the winter. We enjoy Sunday brunch on Little Palm Island. Pricey but worth the money. Also we enjoy brunch at the Westin in Key West. You have to see Mallory Square at sunset. The drive from Miami to Key West should be done at least one time in your life.

  4. Kay Higdon|

    I am not sure everyone who subscribes can afford the over $200 per night hotels you mention. I surely cannot, even though it sounds wonderful to have the advantages, and experiences you mention. Why would it surprise you to get refills on non-alcoholic beverages? Every place here, where I live, has this for the diner.

Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *

Exit mobile version